Actions

Work Header

The Cruelest Mercy

Summary:

At fifteen, Percy learned he was going to die. The prophecy promised it.

But Luke died instead. Then Leo. Then everyone except him.

Percy kept surviving when he shouldn’t, when he didn’t want to, when others burned in his place.

 

“Percy stared at his hands, at the blood drying in the creases of his palms, and tried to understand.

Tried to make it make sense. The hero's soul, cursed blade shall reap.

His blade.

Someone else's soul.

The math didn't work. The prophecy didn't work.

He didn't work, still breathing, still alive, still wrong.”

Notes:

Heyyy here’s a fic T-T I was crying writing it.

Also:
Tw: suicidal thoughts (kinda)

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

At fifteen years old, Percy knew he was going to die.

 

A half-blood of the eldest gods 

Shall reach sixteen against all odds

And see the world in endless sleep

The hero’s soul, cursed blade shall reap

A single choice shall end his days

Olympus to preserve or raze.”

 

They called it a prophecy. Percy called it a countdown. 

 

The words echoed around the room as he finished the last line. The silence pushed down on him. Six lines. That was all it took to write his ending.

He tried to laugh it off. Prophecies are always dramatic, Chiron had said, like that made it better. It might not mean you, Annabeth had reasoned. But the words stuck, curling around his ribs and settling somewhere deep. Squeezing the breath out of his lungs. Already preparing him for his grave.

 

He didn’t talk about it again. Not to Annabeth, not to Grover, not even to himself. He was only 15 for gods sake. 

 

A single choice shall end his days.” 

And he couldn’t decide if it was a blessing or a curse.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/

 

At sixteen years old, Percy watched someone else die for him.

The prophecy had been wrong. Or he'd read it wrong. Or the Fates were cruel in ways he hadn't imagined yet. He couldn't tell anymore, standing on broken concrete while Manhattan woke up around him and Luke's blood cooled on his hands.

It should have been him. The cursed blade in his hand, Riptide, still humming with the aftermath of battle. The hero's soul reaped—but not his soul. Luke's. Luke's eyes going from gold to blue to nothing. Luke's hand going slack. Luke's body crumpling like the prophecy had reached out and chosen the wrong half-blood, the wrong hero, the wrong ending.

He'd made it to sixteen. Against all odds. The words tasted like ash now, like a joke he didn't understand the punchline to.

He'd been so sure. So certain that when Kronos came for him, when Backbiter swung toward his chest, that would be it. The countdown would hit zero. The prophecy would close around him like a fist and squeeze until there was nothing left but another name on the memorial wall at camp.

But he was still standing.

Luke wasn't.

Percy stared at his hands, at the blood drying in the creases of his palms, and tried to understand. Tried to make it make sense. The hero's soul, cursed blade shall reap. His blade. Someone else's soul. The math didn't work. The prophecy didn't work. He didn't work, still breathing, still alive, still wrong.

A single choice shall end his days.

Luke had chosen. Had driven that knife into his own body, into the place where Kronos couldn't hold on, and ended it. Ended himself. Ended the war. Ended everything except Percy, who was supposed to be dead, who had spent a year walking around like a ghost waiting to happen, who had memorized the taste of his own mortality and couldn't spit it out.

Around him, mortals stumbled awake. Confused. Alive. Saved.

Percy wanted to scream at them. Wanted to ask why they got to wake up when Luke didn't. Why he got to wake up. Why the prophecy had carved out a space for his death and then shoved someone else into it at the last second.

Annabeth would find him soon. Would say something about victory, about sacrifice, about how Luke chose to be a hero at the end. Would try to make it mean something.

But Percy couldn't stop thinking about the way Luke's eyes had cleared right before the end. Blue and human and terrified. Couldn't stop thinking about how he'd been ready—so ready—to die, had made peace with it, had built his entire sixteenth year around the fact that he wouldn't see seventeen.

And now he would.

He would see seventeen. Eighteen. Twenty. However many years the Fates felt like giving him, however many years he'd stolen from Luke by surviving.

The prophecy was supposed to be his. The ending was supposed to be his. He'd practiced it in his head a thousand times, had written himself into that final line like his name was already carved on a tombstone.

A single choice shall end his days.

Not Percy's days. Luke's days. And Percy's choice—what? To live? To let someone else pay the price? To stand here covered in his friend's blood and wonder why the universe had decided he was worth more than a prophecy?

He wasn't.

He wasn't worth this.

His knees felt weak. His hands wouldn't stop shaking. The invincibility from the River Styx was still holding, still keeping his body intact, but it felt like a lie now. Like armor he didn't deserve. Like he was cheating at something, except he didn't know the rules and couldn't figure out how to lose.

Olympus still stood. Manhattan was waking. The gods would probably throw a party, give out medals, pretend that this was how it was always supposed to go.

But Percy knew the truth.

He was supposed to be dead.

Luke was supposed to be alive.

And somewhere between the prophecy and the knife and the choice, the world had gotten it backwards.

At sixteen years old, Percy learned that surviving could feel worse than dying.

The prophecy had been fulfilled.

He just didn't understand why he was still here to see it.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\

Percy couldn't figure out how to die.

The gorgons had been chasing him for days. Weeks. Months? Time felt slippery, like trying to hold water in his hands. Everything felt slippery. His name. His past. The reason why he was running south with nothing on his back and bronze claws slashing at his heels every few miles.

He should be dead by now. He knew that much, even if he didn't know anything else. Knew it in the same way he knew how to fight, how to breathe, how to uncap the pen in his pocket and watch it become a sword. Instinct. Muscle memory. The certainty that he was living on borrowed time.

The gorgons attacked again at sunset. He barely had time to uncap his sword before the first one was on him, talons aimed at his throat. He brought his sword up and felt the impact shudder through his arms. She hissed, pulled back, lunged again.

He should have been tired. Should have been slow. Should have made a mistake by now, after however many days this had been. But his body moved like it didn't know how to stop, didn't know how to fail. Every strike that should have connected slid off. Every wound that should have opened stayed closed. Every moment that should have been his last just kept going.

It was wrong. All of it was wrong.

The second gorgon came at him from behind and he spun, drove his sword through her chest, watched her explode into dust. She'd reform. They always reformed. They'd be back in an hour, maybe less, ready to try again. Ready to kill him. Except they couldn't.

And he didn't know why.

His body knew things his mind didn't. Knew how to fight, how to move, how to survive. Knew that there was a small spot on his back that felt different from the rest of him, vulnerable and vital and wrong. Knew that he was supposed to protect it. Knew that as long as he did, nothing could hurt him.

But he didn't know why he knew that.

Didn't know why his skin felt like armor. Why his muscles didn't burn with exhaustion. Why he could run for miles and miles and barely feel winded. Why the gorgons' poison-tipped claws left nothing but torn fabric and frustration.

He wasn't actually tired. Wasn't actually hurt. Wasn't actually anything except confused and wrong and still alive when he shouldn't be.

There was a word tickling the back of his mind. A river. A choice. A curse that wasn't a curse, or maybe it was, he couldn't remember. Couldn't remember anything except the feeling of water closing over his head and the certainty that he'd done something irreversible.

The gorgons would be back soon. They always came back. And he would fight them off again, and survive again, and keep running toward a destination he couldn't name with a purpose he couldn't remember.

He was a weapon that didn't know what war it was fighting.

A body without a past.

A boy who couldn't die and couldn't remember why he was supposed to.

He knew he'd lost something. Someone. Multiple someones. Knew it the way he knew how to breathe, fundamental and aching. There were spaces in his mind where people should be. Where memories should be. Where a life should be.

But all he had was this. Running. Fighting. Surviving.

Always surviving.

The gorgons came back an hour later, right on schedule. He fought them off with mechanical precision, watched them dissolve into dust, and tried not to think about how easy it was. How wrong it felt to be this unkillable. How his body moved like it was made for this, made to endure, made to last, and his mind was just screaming why why why.

There had to be a reason. Had to be a purpose. Had to be something that explained why he was walking around in a body that refused to break, with a past he couldn't access and a future he couldn't imagine.

The small of his back burned like it was trying to remind him of something. Like it held the answer. But when he reached for it, tried to understand it, there was nothing but fog and the feeling of water and a choice he couldn't remember making.

Lupa said he was going to a camp. Said there were others like him. Said he had a destiny.

Percy wanted to laugh. Destiny. What destiny could he have when he didn't even know who he was? When he was just a collection of instincts and scars he couldn't remember earning and an immortality he didn't understand?

The gorgons attacked again at dawn.

He cut them down without thinking.

And wondered, as he always did, why he was still here.

Why he couldn't die.

Why no one had told him that forgetting yourself was worse than any wound, worse than any death, worse than anything except this—

Being alive and having no idea why.

Percy learned that you could lose everything and still keep breathing.

Your name. Your past. Your people. Your purpose.

Everything except the curse that kept you alive to feel it.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\

 

At seventeen years old, Percy was certain Tartarus would finally finish what the prophecy started.

The air was poison. Literally. Every breath tasted like sulfur and death and the ground-up bones of everything that had ever been foolish enough to die here. His lungs should have been shredded by now. His throat should have closed up. His body should have done what bodies were supposed to do when introduced to an environment specifically designed to kill gods, let alone demigods.

The River Styx's curse was gone. Washed away when he crossed the Little Tiber, stripped away like it had never been there at all. He was mortal now. Fully mortal. Vulnerable in every way that mattered.

And he was still breathing.

Still walking.

Still surviving.

Annabeth stumbled beside him, and his hand shot out to catch her before his brain even registered she was falling. She was hurt. They were both hurt. Cuts and bruises and things that felt deeper, worse, fundamental. The kind of damage that should have been permanent. The kind that should have killed them hours ago.

He'd fallen into hell to save her. Had grabbed her hand as she dangled over the edge and made the choice in a split second—let go and live, or hold on and fall.

It hadn't felt like a choice at all.

They should be dead. Both of them. The poison air alone should have done it. The monsters should have done it. The rivers of fire and the endless darkness and the sheer concentrated evil of the place should have done it.

But they kept going.

Percy didn't understand. Had stopped trying to understand. He was mortal now, just flesh and blood and determination, no divine protection, no curse to keep him standing. Just him. And it wasn't enough. It shouldn't be enough. Nothing about him should be enough to survive this.

But every time a monster came, he fought it off. Every time Annabeth fell, he caught her. Every time the ground opened up or the air burned or something tried to drag them deeper, he found a way. Found water where there shouldn't be water. Found strength where there shouldn't be strength. Found another breath, another step, another moment of not dying.

It felt like a joke. Like the universe was laughing at him. Percy thought of the Curse of Achilles. And now that it was gone—now that he was finally, actually mortal—he still couldn't die.

Annabeth was suffering. He could see it in the way she moved, mechanical and determined, pushing past her limits because stopping meant death. Her lips were cracked. Her eyes were shadowed. She was breaking down here, piece by piece, because she was human and this place was designed to destroy humanity.

And Percy was breaking too. Could feel it in every wound that didn't heal, every breath that hurt, every step that sent pain shooting through his legs. He was mortal. He was dying, slowly, by inches.

Just not fast enough.

The guilt was worse than the poison air. Worse than the monsters. Worse than knowing that every step deeper was a step farther from any chance of escape. Because he'd done this. He'd brought her here. And they were both dying but neither of them was dead and he couldn't tell if that was hope or just prolonged torture.

He'd wanted to die for her. Expected to. Expected that falling into Tartarus would be the end, the final sacrifice, the thing that made sense after years of prophecies and countdowns and surviving when he shouldn't.

But Tartarus didn't want to give him that mercy.

It wanted them to suffer first. Wanted them to crawl and bleed and break. Wanted them to know, intimately, exactly how mortal they were before it finally finished them off.

Percy's body screamed with every movement now. No invulnerability to dull the pain. No curse to keep his muscles from tearing, his bones from aching, his skin from blistering in the caustic air. He was human. Fragile. Temporary.

So why wasn't he dead yet?

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\

 

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that survival didn't make you human.

The bodies had dissolved into the darkness, leaving nothing behind but the memory of what he'd done. What he was capable of. The goddess Akhlys, on her knees, choking on her own poison while Percy held it there. Held it in her lungs. In her throat. In every part of her that should have been divine and untouchable.

He'd wanted her to suffer. Wanted her to feel what Annabeth felt, what they both felt. Wanted to make everything that had hurt them hurt worse.

And he could have. Could have killed her. Could have torn the poison through her body until there was nothing left but divine ichor and the satisfaction of revenge.

Annabeth's voice had stopped him. But the want hadn't gone away. The capability hadn't disappeared. The knowledge of what he could do—what he'd enjoyed doing—sat in his chest like a stone.

He'd controlled poison. In Tartarus. Had bent it to his will the same way he bent water, natural and easy and wrong. Had felt powerful for the first time since falling into this pit, and the power had felt good.

That's what scared him most. Not that he'd done it. But that he'd liked it.

He was mortal now. Completely mortal. No curse to blame, no invulnerability to hide behind. Just him and the poison and the choice to make a goddess beg.

And he'd made that choice.

The death mist clung to his skin now, making him look like something he wasn't. Making him look dead. And Percy couldn't shake the feeling that it was more honest than his actual face. That this—this corpse-like thing wearing his shape—was closer to the truth than the boy who'd walked into Tartarus thinking he was a hero.

Heroes didn't torture goddesses. Heroes didn't find satisfaction in suffering. Heroes didn't look at their girlfriend with scared eyes and see fear looking back.

But survivors did. Survivors did whatever it took. Survivors crossed lines and justified it later. Survivors kept breathing no matter what it cost, no matter what they became.

And Percy was so tired of surviving.

He was mortal. Fragile. Human. Should have been dead a dozen times over by now, should have been just another corpse in the pit. But he kept going. Kept finding ways. Kept discovering new things he could do, new lines he could cross, new pieces of himself he could sacrifice to buy another hour of life.

He'd wanted to live once, back when he was young and stupid and thought living was real. Had wanted to survive long enough to make a difference. Had wanted to be the one who lived when everyone else fell.

And then he found out he was doomed to die. But he was still surviving. Still living. Still breathing.

And he was starting to think that was worse.

Annabeth walked ahead of him, wrapped in her own death mist, and Percy followed. That's all he could do. Follow. Survive. Keep putting one foot in front of the other and pretend he didn't see the way she looked at him sometimes now. Like she was trying to recognize someone she used to know.

He didn't recognize himself either.

The boy who'd worried about prophecies and dying heroically felt like a stranger. That boy had thought death was the worst thing that could happen. Had thought surviving was winning.

This boy—the one walking through Tartarus wearing a corpse's face and carrying the memory of poison in his veins—knew better.

There were worse things than dying.

Like living with what you'd become. Like surviving when you'd lost the parts of yourself that made survival worth it. Like looking at your hands and knowing what they were capable of and wondering if you'd do it again.

Wondering if next time, you'd like it even more.

He was mortal. Human. Vulnerable. Everything the curse had protected him from, he felt now. Every wound, every breath of poison air, every moment of pain.

But he was still alive.

Still surviving.

And Percy was starting to think that maybe the curse had never been the problem. Maybe he was just built wrong from the start. Built to survive when he shouldn't. Built to keep going when stopping would be kinder. Built to live through things that should have killed him and come out the other side as something that didn't deserve to be alive.

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that you didn't need a curse to become a monster.

Just enough time in hell and the will to do whatever it took to survive it.

The gods didn't need to punish him.

He was doing a fine job of that himself.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\

 

At seventeen years old, Percy thought the ocean would be the one to finally let him go.

Polybotes swiped his hand through the water and the poison spread like ink, dark and deadly and inevitable. Percy should have pulled back. Should have retreated. Should have done anything except what he did.

He swam straight into it.

The poison hit him like a wall, seeping into his skin, his lungs, his blood. Burning. Dissolving. Killing him in the one place he'd always felt safe. The ocean had always healed him, always welcomed him, always felt like home.

Now it was full of poison and he'd chosen to swim into it anyway.

The irony was perfect. Beautiful, even. Son of Poseidon, dying in salt water because he'd run toward death instead of away from it. He couldn't tell if it was instinct or exhaustion or if some broken part of him had finally gotten what it wanted.

His sword slipped from his fingers. Riptide tumbled away into the darkness and Percy didn't reach for it. Didn't try to catch it. Just watched it fall the same way he was falling, sinking, letting the poison and the ocean pull him down.

He was so tired.

Years of tired. Lifetimes of tired. The kind of tired that sleep couldn't fix, that rest couldn't touch. Tired of prophecies and close calls and waking up confused about why he was still breathing. Tired of surviving when everyone else didn't. Tired of being saved. Tired of saving. Tired of being the one who lived.

Just tired.

The poison was spreading faster now, no longer meeting any resistance. His demigod healing had given up. Or maybe he'd told it to give up. He couldn't tell anymore where his body ended and his choice began.

Above him, he could sense the fight continuing. Jason and Polybotes. Lightning and storms and heroism. Jason would win. Jason always won. But it would take time. Minutes, maybe. Precious minutes that Percy wouldn't have.

Perfect.

He sank deeper, the water pressure increasing, the poison working its way into every cell. His heart was slowing. His lungs were burning. His vision was going dark at the edges, black bleeding in like the poison, like the ocean, like the end he'd been waiting for.

This was it.

Finally.

No more fighting. No more surviving. No more waking up and having to figure out why he deserved another day. No more becoming things he didn't recognize. No more hating himself for living when Luke died. No more carrying the weight of Tartarus and poison and every choice that had carved pieces out of his soul.

Just rest.

The ocean was quiet down here. Peaceful. The poison didn't hurt anymore, or maybe he just couldn't feel it. Couldn't feel anything except a spreading numbness that felt like mercy.

He thought about his mom. About Annabeth. About Grover and all the people who would be sad. But the guilt couldn't reach him anymore. Nothing could reach him. He was too far down, too far gone, too ready to let go.

Death was right there. He could feel it. Not scary. Not cruel. Just gentle and final and everything he'd needed since he was fifteen years old and learned that he was supposed to die.

He'd just been early. That was all. The prophecy had said sixteen. He'd made it to seventeen. Close enough.

His eyes drifted closed. His heart stuttered once, twice, then barely at all. The ocean cradled him like a mother, like home, like the grave he'd been walking toward since the first line of prophecy.

Come on, he thought. Please. I'm ready. I'm so ready.

And death reached for him.

He felt it. The moment. The edge. The final letting go. His heart stopped. His lungs stilled. Everything that had been Percy Jackson started to drift away like sand through fingers.

Perfect.

And then hands grabbed him.

No.

Jason's hands, pulling him up, away from the bottom, away from the peace he'd finally found. Jason's lightning-charged touch jolting his stopped heart back into motion. Jason's power forcing air back into his lungs.

No no no no—

Percy wanted to fight. Wanted to push him away. Wanted to sink back down to where death was waiting. But his body wouldn't cooperate. His traitorous, survival-programmed, refuses-to-die body was responding to Jason's rescue. His heart was beating. His lungs were working. The ocean was healing him.

He was coming back.

Jason pulled him to clean water, away from the poison cloud. The water that should have been his grave was now saving him, washing the poison from his system, knitting his cells back together, making him whole again.

Making him alive again.

Percy's eyes opened. He didn't want them to. Wanted to keep them closed, wanted to sink back into that darkness, but his body wasn't his anymore. Had never been his. Was just this thing that kept surviving no matter what he wanted.

They were sitting on the ocean floor. Jason was there, solid and real and victorious. He'd defeated the giant. Had come down here fast enough. Had saved Percy just in time.

Just in time to ruin everything.

Jason's mouth was moving. Talking. Probably asking if Percy was okay, probably relieved, probably being the perfect hero he always was.

And Percy felt it building in his chest. Hot and ugly and so intense it almost felt like the poison again. But worse. Because the poison had been trying to free him and this—this was rage. Resentment.

Hatred.

He hated Jason.

Hated him with every cell that was still alive, every breath his lungs were taking, every beat of his traitorous heart. Hated his perfect timing. Hated his heroism. Hated that he'd won his fight fast enough. Hated that he'd cared enough to come down here. Hated that he'd pulled Percy back from the edge.

Percy had been ready. Had been done. Had finally, finally reached the end. Death had taken him. His heart had stopped. He'd let go.

And Jason had dragged him back.

Had forced life back into a body that didn't want it anymore. Had saved him from the one thing Percy had wanted more than anything. Had given him another day, another week, another year of this endless, exhausting existence.

The water was healing him completely now. The poison was gone. His strength was returning. In a few minutes, he'd be fine. Perfectly fine. Good as new.

Like nothing had happened.

Like he hadn't just had everything he wanted ripped away at the last possible second.

Jason was still talking, smiling now, that relieved smile that people wore when they thought they'd saved someone. When they thought they'd done something good.

Percy made his face do something back. Something that probably looked like gratitude. Like relief. Like he was happy to be alive.

But underneath, in the parts of himself he would never show, the hatred burned. Quiet and vicious and unforgivable.

Not fair. He knew that. Not Jason's fault. Jason was a hero doing hero things. Jason had saved his friend. Jason had done everything right.

But Percy had been so close. Had felt death's hand in his. Had been seconds away from peace.

And Jason had stolen it from him.

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that you could hate someone for saving your life.

That being pulled back from death felt worse than dying.

That the cruelest thing someone could do was refuse to let you go.

The ocean around them was clear. Clean. Perfect for healing. For living.

And Percy sat in it, whole and alive and seething with a resentment he could never voice.

Jason had saved him.

Percy would never forgive him for it.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/

 

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that even his blood was a weapon.

The giant hit him hard enough that he felt his ribs crack before he felt the wall. The impact drove the air from his lungs, drove sense from his head, drove him into the stone hard enough that something in his face broke.

His nose. Definitely his nose. He could feel it, the sharp crack, the immediate flood of warmth down his face, his lips, his chin. Blood. His blood.

He slid down the wall and hit the ground, and his blood went with him. Dripping. Falling. Soaking into the earth.

The earth.

Gaea.

No.

The thought was distant, muffled by pain and the ringing in his ears and the way his vision was going grey at the edges. But it was there. Clear and terrible and too late.

His blood was hitting the ground. Was seeping into the soil. Was feeding the one thing that should never, ever be fed.

He tried to move. Tried to get up, tried to stop the bleeding, tried to do anything except lie there and watch his blood pool on the floor like an offering. Like a sacrifice. Like the final piece of a ritual he'd never meant to complete.

But his body wouldn't cooperate. His ribs were screaming. His head was spinning. His nose was gushing blood faster than he could process, faster than he could stop, faster than he could take back.

Around him, he could feel it starting. The earth shifting. Warming. Waking.

No no no no—

This couldn't be it. This couldn't be how it ended. Not with his blood. Not with his failure. Not with him lying broken on the ground while the worst thing in the world stirred to life because he'd been too slow, too weak, too mortal to avoid a single hit.

He'd survived prophecies. Survived Tartarus. Survived poison in the ocean and torture and battles that should have killed him a hundred times over.

And this—a broken nose and bad timing—this was going to be what doomed everyone.

The thought would have been funny if it wasn't so horrifying.

His friends were fighting around him. He could hear them. Voices shouting, weapons clashing, the sounds of desperation. They were trying. Everyone was trying. And he was lying here bleeding the world awake.

He pressed his hand to his face, trying to stop the flow, but it was too late. Too much. The blood had already fallen. Had already seeped into Gaea's skin. Had already done what prophecies and giants and monsters couldn't do.

Wake her up.

Percy had spent years expecting to die heroically. In battle. Protecting someone. Making a choice that mattered. Going out in a way that meant something.

Not this. Not bleeding on the floor while his body gave the enemy exactly what she needed. Not being the weapon used against everyone he loved.

The ground was trembling now. He could feel it through his broken ribs, through his shaking hands, through every part of him that was still conscious enough to understand what was happening.

Gaea was rising.

Because of him.

His blood had been the key. His mortality. His weakness. His complete failure to do the one job he'd had—don't bleed on the ground.

And he'd failed.

The grey at the edges of his vision was spreading, going dark. Concussion, probably. Blood loss, definitely. His body trying to shut down, trying to escape what his consciousness couldn't.

But he couldn't pass out. Couldn't let go. Not when this was his fault. Not when his blood was soaking into the earth and waking up the apocalypse.

He tried to get up again. Tried to force his broken body to move, to fight, to do something other than lie here and be the catalyst for the end of everything.

His arms gave out. His ribs protested with sharp, breathtaking pain. His head swam.

He collapsed back down and more blood fell from his face. More fuel for the monster. More of his failure soaking into the ground.

Someone was screaming his name. Annabeth, maybe. Or Hazel. Someone who cared, someone who would try to save him, someone who didn't understand that he was past saving. That he'd already done the damage.

That his blood was worth more to Gaea than his life had ever been to anyone else.

The earth was fully awake now. He could feel her consciousness spreading, stretching, filling the ground beneath him. His blood had given her that. His weakness. His mortality. His complete inability to do the one thing that mattered.

Stay alive without bleeding.

And he'd failed at even that.

Percy had always known he was going to die. Had expected it. Had been ready for it. Had even wanted it, sometimes, when the weight of surviving got too heavy.

But he'd never imagined it would be like this. Useful to the enemy. A tool. A sacrifice that helped the wrong side.

His blood was the last piece. The final ingredient. The thing that made the impossible possible.

And he'd given it freely. Not through choice. Not through heroism. Just through being mortal enough to break. Human enough to bleed. Weak enough to fail when it mattered most.

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that sometimes dying wasn't the worst thing you could do.

Sometimes the worst thing was staying alive long enough to give the enemy exactly what they needed.

His blood on the ground.

Gaea awake.

The world ending.

All because he'd survived everything else just to fail at this.

 

/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\

 

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that some battles you win by dying.

And he wasn't the one who got to die.

Gaea was there. Fully awake. Fully formed. A woman made of earth and malice, towering over Camp Half-Blood like a vengeful god. His blood had done that. His failure. His weakness. And now she was here to end everything.

The sky above them was wrong. Burning. The Argo II was up there somewhere, with Leo, with the plan that required someone to die. The fire of life. The cure for death. The cost that someone had to pay.

Percy fought on the ground with his sword in his hand and death in his lungs. Every breath tasted like ash. Every movement sent pain through his still-broken ribs. His face was caked with dried blood—the blood that had started all this—and fresh blood from new wounds, because Gaea's monsters didn't care if he was already broken.

They just wanted him more broken.

He cut down a giant that had been trying to tear through the cabins. Watched it crumble to dust. Another one rose up to take its place. They always did. Always more monsters. Always more death. Always more failure.

Around him, campers were falling. Kids. Teenagers. Children who should have been learning algebra and going to proms and figuring out who they were. Instead they were bleeding on the ground because he'd woken up the Earth and brought this war to their doorstep.

His fault. All of it. Every body. Every scream. Every life ended before it had a chance to begin.

He should have bled out on that floor. Should have let the concussion take him. Should have died before his blood could wake her up. But no—he'd survived. He always survived. And other people always paid for it.

The sky exploded.

Not exploded. Burst. Fractured. Lit up with fire so bright it burned his eyes even through the smoke and chaos. The Argo II. Leo.

No.

Percy knew what that light meant. Knew it in his bones, in his blood, in the part of him that had been expecting this since the moment he learned about the prophecy. To storm or fire the world must fall.

Fire. Leo. Dying.

While Percy stayed on the ground with his sword and his guilt and his stubborn refusal to be the one who died.

Gaea was screaming. Or maybe that was the earth itself, cracking, breaking, losing its goddess. The ground beneath Percy's feet shook so hard he fell to his knees. His ribs protested. His vision swam. He watched through blurred eyes as Gaea fell—really fell—burning from the sky like a meteor, like divine justice, like the end of everything wrapped in fire.

She hit the ground and the world shook harder. Dust rose up in clouds. The sound was deafening. Final.

And then silence.

The kind of silence that came after endings. After sacrifices. After someone traded their life for everyone else's.

Leo.

Percy tried to stand. Couldn't. His legs wouldn't work. His body was finally giving up, shutting down, doing what it should have done hours ago. Days ago. Years ago.

But it was too late now. Too late to trade places. Too late to be the one burning in the sky. Too late to do anything except kneel in the rubble and understand what had just happened.

Leo had died.

Leo had sacrificed himself.

Leo had done what Percy was supposed to do. What Percy had been preparing to do since he was fifteen years old. What every prophecy and close call and moment of almost-dying had been leading to.

And Percy had survived it.

Again.

Always again.

He thought he might be screaming. Couldn't tell. His throat was raw, his lungs were full of ash, and everything was grey and terrible and wrong. The battle was over. Gaea was gone. The monsters were dissolving into nothing.

Victory.

They'd call it victory.

Percy called it theft.

Leo had stolen his death. Had taken the ending that was supposed to be Percy's. Had burned in the sky while Percy knelt on the ground covered in blood that wasn't even enough—wasn't worth enough—to pay for what he'd caused.

Around him, people were celebrating. Crying. Hugging. Alive because Leo wasn't. Saved because Leo had burned.

Percy wanted to burn too. Wanted to trade places. Wanted to go back in time and be the one on that ship, be the one with the fire, be the one who finally—finally—did what he was supposed to do and died for something.

But time didn't work that way. Death didn't work that way. The universe had decided that Percy Jackson was going to survive, and it didn't matter how many people had to die in his place.

Luke. The kids at camp. Leo.

Always someone else. Never him.

His hands were shaking. His whole body was shaking. He pressed his palms into the ground—Gaea's ground, the earth he'd woken up with his blood—and tried to breathe.

Tried to understand why he was still breathing when Leo wasn't.

He'd failed. Had failed at every single thing that mattered. Failed to avoid bleeding. Failed to stop Gaea from waking. Failed to be the one who died stopping her. Failed to protect Leo. Failed to do anything except survive while better people burned.

The guilt was crushing him. Heavier than the sky had been. Heavier than Tartarus. Heavier than every monster he'd ever fought. It was inside him, replacing his lungs, his heart, his ability to think of anything except Leo burning and Percy living and how fundamentally wrong that was.

He should have been up there. Should have been the fire. Should have been the storm. Should have been the one trading his life for the world.

That's what prophecies promised. That's what heroes did. They died saving people.

But not Percy. Percy just survived. Percy just kept breathing while everyone else paid his debts.

Someone was pulling him up. Annabeth probably. Her voice in his ear, saying something he couldn't hear. Telling him it was over. That they'd won. That it was okay.

It wasn't okay.

Nothing was okay.

Leo was dead and Percy was alive and the math didn't work. The universe had gotten it backwards. Had taken the wrong person. Had let the wrong hero burn.

Percy had spent years preparing to die. Had made peace with it. Had wanted it, sometimes, when the weight got too heavy. And when the moment finally came—when someone finally had to burn—it wasn't him.

It was never him.

He was the hero who lived. The one who survived. The one who got to walk away from the ashes and the bodies and the sacrifices and keep going. Keep breathing. Keep existing in a world that he'd helped save by doing nothing except failing to die.

His ribs hurt. His face hurt. His whole body hurt. But it was nothing compared to the weight in his chest, the knowledge that he'd carry for the rest of his life however long that turned out to be.

Leo had died for him. For all of them. For the world.

And Percy had let him.

Had stood on the ground with his sword and his broken ribs and watched the sky burn. Had survived another prophecy. Another battle. Another ending that should have been his.

At seventeen years old, Percy learned that being the hero who lived was worse than being the hero who died.

The dead got to rest. Got to be remembered as brave. Got to have their sacrifice mean something clean and pure and final.

The living had to carry it. Had to wake up every day and remember who died in their place. Had to look at themselves in the mirror and see someone who should have burned but didn't.

Had to survive.

And surviving felt like the cruelest punishment the Fates could devise.

Percy knelt in the ruins of Camp Half-Blood, covered in blood and ash, and understood with perfect clarity that he would carry this forever.

Luke. The campers. Leo.

Everyone who died so he could live.

Victory tasted like ashes.

And Percy was so tired of surviving it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Notes:

Please comment and leave kudos!