All for the "What If"s
Series Metadata
Listing Series
-
Tags
Summary
“Arghhh…. ‘ndrew?” he slurs out, lifting head to squint around the room.
Suddenly he is very awake.
There’s a man in his room that he doesn’t recognize.
In one hand he holds a smoking cigarette between slender, scared fingers.
In the other he holds a handgun aimed casually at Kevin’s prone form.
He’s mid drag of his cigarette when Kevin freezes, going cold all over.
Petal pink lips curve upwards around the cancer stick, the cherry red butt glowing softly.
“Good morning, Kevin Day.”
or
What if Neil was given to the first branch instead of the second?
or
Nathaniel Wesninski was always going to be Ichirou's Butcher.
Series
- Part 1 of All for the "What If"s
- Part 1 of Butcher!Neil AU
-
Tags
Summary
It’s the hoodie that Andrew notices first, bright white and loose with a fluffy hood pulled over auburn hair. The only spots of color being the pink pocket on the belly and the pink insides of the two floppy ears attached to the hood.
Next is the thighs, lean, honey brown and peppered with freckles. Andrew’s eyes catch on a thin white scar slicing through the soft skin of his left inner thigh. Andrew can’t see any pants. Is he not wearing pants?
or
What if Neil and Kevin were one year ahead of the Monsters at Palmetto and Neil had to protect Kevin for his first year?
or
Neil puts on a rabbit hoodie and ruins freshman Andrew's day
Series
- Part 2 of All for the "What If"s
-
Tags
Summary
The Bear seems to be catching on as well, his face twisted into irritation as he takes another swing at Neil’s head. This time Neil spins away and around to the man’s back, slapping him upside the head as he bounces out of range.
“Oh ho ho ho!” the announcer laughs brightly. “It looks like our favorite rabbit is feeling feisty today!”
or
What if Neil lost the money Mary stole from Nathan and all her resources when she died? What if he had no hope of survival without it? What if he turned to questionable methods to get money?
or
Street fighter Neil AU
Series
- Part 3 of All for the "What If"s
- Part 1 of street fighter!Neil au
-
Tags
Summary
“Neil Hatford, seventeen year old son of Mary Hatford and student at Millport High School, was found last night at the brutal murder site of Jackson Plank.”
or
What if Nathan wasn't part of the mob? What if Neil was a different kind of fox? (The Medicated Neil au)
or
Neil kills for his mother and has to face the consequences. The Foxes may be his only opportunity to live.
Series
- Part 4 of All for the "What If"s
-
second son (first daughter) by bees_in_eyeliner
Fandoms: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
09 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
They say every Wesninski has four children.
The first to be his father’s son.
The daughter is their mother’s.
The second son is to die.
The second daughter is the spare.
Nathan Wesninski was the first of his father’s sons. The first, the strongest, and the fastest.
They say he killed his siblings, a future monarch slitting his siblings throats as they rocked in their cradles.
Natalia was Nathan’s first daughter, his second child.
or
What if the Wesninski's were their own mafia family? What if they are just as powerful as the Moriyama's?
or
Mafia heir Nathaniel plots to cut Nathan's fucking head off.
Series
- Part 5 of All for the "What If"s
-
Tags
Summary
Jean’s partner gets dumped at his feet when he’s thirteen and Nathaniel is twelve. Jean never does find out where exactly Nathaniel came from with a broken nose and a swollen eye. Knowing what he does now it could have been anything from him running his stupid mouth to Tetsuji or a parting gift from his father.
Either way Nathaniel Wesninski comes to him bloody but unbroken. (He always does.)
or
What if Jean got the partner he always deserved?
or
Raven Neil and Jean as ride or die partners.
Series
- Part 6 of All for the "What If"s
-
Tags
Summary
Before his attacker can lay another hand on him (before he’d run out of time, before his fantasy of living is up, before they take him up to his father-) he turns into them, grabbing the wrist of the hand that has a grip on him and yanking them forward. They yelp (above his head, they’re taller than him then) but he ignores the sound, darting out a hand to clamp it over the back of their neck (long hair brushes against his hand, past their neck, female?) and hooking his leg around to sweep their legs out from under them. He puts them hard onto the library floor.
A red haired girl stares up at him with wide, shocked eyes. Her hair, tied up in a perfect blue bow, fans out around her, russet curls framing her pale face. She’s dressed in a white shirt with a soft-booking baby blue sweater and a pleated blue skirt. Her tennis shoes are cleaner than anything Neil has ever owned and her knee-high socks are patterned with cartoon bunnies on a solid blue background.
They stare at each other for a moment, she’s breathing just as hard as Neil, and he can’t tell which one of them is more startled by what just happened.
or
What if Kate and Neil became friends early in canon?
Series
- Part 7 of All for the "What If"s
-
Tags
Summary
“Butcher’s boy.” Marley says. “Freak.” Harry says. “Feral.” Bobby says. “Fucking crazy.” Jackie says.
“You really his kid?”
or
5 times Natalie Sheilds and Abram Wesninski talked about everything and anything +1 the one time they couldn't
+1 plus the one time...or
What if Natalie and Abram grew up together in Nathan's gang? What if they were all they had? What if they lost everything?
Series
- Part 8 of All for the "What If"s
-
got this anxious feeling (goes away for a minute when i'm with you, breathing) by bees_in_eyeliner
Fandoms: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
30 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
A man was pinning Andrew to the bed, large, tattooed, muscular, and with far too much skin showing. Neil looks down at his half-undone pants and his hand that kept Andrew’s face half buried in his own blood. There was so much red, vivid against the soft white sheets. Andrew’s knuckles stood out against the dark wood of the headboard that he clutched for dear life.
Every thought fell out of Neil’s head as his eyes returned to the dead man holding Andrew down.
or
Street fighter!Neil gets to Drake first
or
prt 2 to "rock your shit" (PLEASE READ PRT 1 AND THE END NOTES YOU MAY BE A LITTLE CONFUSED OTHERWISE)
Series
- Part 9 of All for the "What If"s
- Part 2 of street fighter!Neil au
-
hope you won't ever lie to me by bees_in_eyeliner
Fandoms: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
05 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
Nathaniel straightens up. “I told you: I’ll make you a deal,” he says. “I can get you what you want.”
“I want nothing.”
Nathaniel’s eyes flash, and there’s far too much understanding in his expression for Andrew’s comfort, but Nathaniel doesn’t comment on it.
“I can get you off the drugs.”
or
Nathaniel reappears at the Columbia house to make a deal with Andrew, and it's not until seven months later, when he shows up tired and hurting, that Andrew realizes he might have bitten off more than he can chew.
or
part two to "Butcher Jr." (PLEASE READ PRT 1 AND THE END NOTES YOU MAY BE A LITTLE CONFUSED OTHERWISE)
Series
- Part 10 of All for the "What If"s
- Part 2 of Butcher!Neil AU
-
swim a lake of fire, walk the floor of any sea by bees_in_eyeliner
Fandoms: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
17 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
The thing in the center of the circle is tall, tall enough that it has to hunch over to fit in their dorm, its shaggy red coat flattened to its body by the ceiling. It is canine, at least most of it seems to be, its body and face shaped like a starved coyote, down to the protruding ribs and long, thin snout. But its limbs are… wrong. They are stretched out and too human for Andrew’s taste, the fingers long and nimble and ending in jagged talons. Its legs are crossed beneath its giant body, mimicking Kevin’s stance. Elegant horns curve over its head, nestled against long, pointed ears. It’s the eyes that make the hair on the back of Andrew’s neck stand on end. They bulge strangely from its face, wet and black. They are accompanied by a wide, permanent grin with thick tusks on its upper and lower jaws. A long prehensile tongue flicks out to lick its chops as it turns to Nicky, silencing his shrieking with one look.
“Natanyel,” Kevin says.
OR
Riko Moriyama has stolen the other half of Natayel's soul. And everyone knows that demons are nothing if not possessive.
Series
- Part 11 of All for the "What If"s